British CNN correspondent Matthew Chance, 56, is suing the Borough Market Trustees for £1.6 million after he slipped and broke his ankle at the central London market on the afternoon of 19 December 2022.
He was on his way to book a table at the market's Roast restaurant when, at about 4pm, he walked in front of a food stall and slipped on an oily, greasy patch of food waste. He lost his footing, twisted his right leg and snapped his ankle in what his lawyers called a Bosworth fracture, in which ligaments are torn from the bone. He was rushed to hospital. The fibula was put back into position, and further surgery repaired the ligament and reconstructed the joint. He has said the injury left him with ongoing pain.
Chance, who earns £425,000 a year, says the injury forced him to move permanently to the UK from his Moscow base. His lawyers argue that UK taxes are higher than Russia's, so his net pay is lower than it would have been had he stayed in Moscow after a later promotion. They said that had he stayed in Moscow, his net pay would have been considerably higher than it is now, and that the injury caused a substantial loss. Barrister James Byrne told the court this week that the fall had knocked him sideways and seriously affected his earning potential. Chance was promoted to CNN's chief global affairs correspondent after the accident. His lawyers say that, had he not relocated, he would have received the higher salary subject only to Russian income tax.
The trustees have admitted liability for the accident but will contest the damages. Defending barrister James Hogg said Chance must prove the incidence, causation, nature and extent of the pain, injury, loss and damage alleged, and that his credibility is in issue. Hogg said Chance told Dr Stallard in November 2024 that he had returned to sedentary work and had not gone back to the same combat or front-line reporting, yet before that date he had reported from Goris in Armenia in October 2023, from Tel Aviv later that month when a broadcast was interrupted by explosions, and from the Gaza-Egyptian border in September 2024 while accompanying the Israel Defence Forces. Hogg also pointed to evidence that, by June 2024, Chance was not taking pain medication and had partly returned to road cycling and to running on a treadmill at 12km/h, described as his previous fast pace.
The case was before the High Court this week for a pre-trial case-management hearing. A five-day trial is currently set for early 2028. Chance joined CNN in 2001 and has reported from the Middle East, Afghanistan, Russia and Chechnya, Ukraine, Europe and the Far East, including interviews with Vladimir Putin, Alexander Lukashenko and Pervez Musharraf. The court papers also record earlier assignments in which he fled Israeli airstrikes in Lebanon, found himself beside a live grenade while broadcasting from Ukraine, interviewed Volodymyr Zelensky in a Kyiv bunker as Russian bombs landed, and was held at gunpoint in a Libyan hotel in 2011.
