In the late 1850s the cage crinoline, a light frame of steel hoops joined by tapes, reached England from France. By about 1862 the skirt stood out in its widest bell. Yards of thin cotton or muslin then hung where a wearer could not easily see them, near an open grate, over a candle on the floor, or beside a revolving shaft in a mill. Literary historian Rebecca N. Mitchell notes that frequent reports of deaths caused by crinoline fire soon appeared, often under sensational titles.
Victorians argued fiercely over how many women the fashion killed. The argument was never settled, because almost nobody was counting in a way that could answer it. The crinoline was an industrial product. An 1862 article cited by Mitchell claimed that Sheffield was turning out 150 tons of crinoline wire every week, and the changing shape kept customers buying.
The danger came from the shape. A hooped skirt swung as its wearer walked, and the hem sat well away from her feet. Mitchell notes that a woman found it hard to judge the sweep of her own skirt near a hearth, and that the swinging motion made that worse. Dresses worn over the hoops were often light muslin, the fabric chemists were then trying to fireproof. A hearth fire, a gas bracket or a candle needed only to reach the outer edge of the hem.
Florence Nightingale, writing in Notes on Nursing in 1860, thought the fashion ridiculous. Her main complaint was practical: “The fidget of silk and of crinoline” disturbed the sick. In a footnote under the heading “Burning of the crinolines,” she went further: “I wish the Registrar-General would tell us the exact number of deaths by burning occasioned by this absurd and hideous custom.” She also passed on a cheap precaution, putting alum into starch, which she said would stop starched clothing from blazing up.
English civil registration did record burns and did separate deaths from clothes catching fire. All the Year Round, Charles Dickens’s weekly, reported in 1862 that in the five years from 1852 to 1856 the registers attributed 9,998 deaths in England and Wales to burns, of which 2,181 were said to have been caused by clothes taking fire. Those years mostly come before the cage crinoline became common. The registers did not record what the victim had been wearing underneath.
The closest systematic local evidence came from coroners. Edwin Lankester, coroner for Central Middlesex, told an inquest in early 1863 that since his appointment he had held 601 inquests, of which 23 involved burns, and that 18 of those had been caused by clothes catching fire. He thought at least two-thirds could have been prevented by non-flammable clothing, and he saw no reason why any child should be put to bed in a flammable nightdress. His numbers concern clothing fires in general, and he did not say how many involved crinolines. The inquest was into a fatal accident at London’s Princess’s Theatre.
At the inquest on 18-year-old Sarah Padley in August 1862, whose muslin dress over a cage crinoline had caught alight, the London Standard reported Lankester calling the case “one of those numerous distressing casualties from the use of the dangerous crinoline.” The jury, on his suggestion, returned a verdict of “Accidental death through wearing crinoline.” He believed such deaths were badly underreported. Mitchell quotes the satirical Anti-Teapot Review arguing that old-fashioned petticoats had caught fire too, but that earlier there were not scores of hungry London newspapers ready to chronicle domestic accidents in the dull season. Mitchell concludes that reports may have been inflated, and that Lankester was adept at supplying quotable lines to the press.
No reliable national figure for crinoline deaths exists in the sources examined. Large round totals that circulate today could not be traced to any official count.
The death most often attached to the crinoline is that of Frances “Fanny” Appleton Longfellow, wife of the poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. On 9 July 1861, in the library of the family house in Cambridge, Massachusetts, a match fallen on the floor set her light summer dress alight. She died the next morning, and Henry Longfellow, confined by severe burns of his own, could not attend the funeral. The National Park Service and Thomas Wentworth Higginson’s 1902 biography give the same dates. None of these accounts mentions a crinoline.
The case of Emily and Mary Wilde, Oscar Wilde’s half-sisters, is harder to document because it was hushed up. Raised in County Monaghan, they attended a Halloween ball in 1871 given by a Mr Reid. A 2006 Irish Times column summarizing Michelle McGoff-McCann’s study of the local coroner’s casebook says Emily, dancing with the host, swung past the open hearth and her dress caught, then Mary’s dress caught as she tried to help. Mary died first and Emily lived until 21 November. The inquest on Mary was reduced to an inquiry after a letter from Sir William Wilde, and the surname was entered as “Wylie.” The column calls Emily’s dress a crinoline. A 2016 Slate account says it was most likely Mary who caught fire first, from candles rather than the hearth, and it gives her death as 9 November while quoting a Northern Standard notice giving the 8th. Alison Matthews David’s Fashion Victims also includes the sisters among its cases.
Fire was not the only hazard. A review of Matthews David’s book reports that in 1860 a Lancashire industrialist banned crinolines among his workers as quite unfitted for factory work, and that girls could be dragged in by printing presses and other machines. A June 1864 report from Cork, known here only from a transcription on a museum blog, concerned a woman in a mangling room whose dress, held out by her crinoline, caught on an uncovered shaft turning about fifty times a minute. She died within hours, and the jury asked for the shaft to be boxed in. Mitchell found a widow who blamed her husband’s fatal fall between two moving boats on a crinoline that blocked the gangway.
Theatres combined gaslight with gauzy costumes. The same review notes Matthews David’s evidence that some dancers resisted flame-retardant treatments because they yellowed the fabric.
The worst disaster linked with crinolines happened far from England. On 8 December 1863 fire broke out during a festival service at the Jesuit church of La Compañía in Santiago, Chile, with about 2,000 worshippers inside, most of them women. Chile’s national library notes that crinoline skirts caught alight or snagged on church furniture and that long dresses tripped people in the crush, while the doors opened inward and could not be forced against the bodies. The skirts were one cause among several. The decorations were flammable and the exits inadequate. In London, Lankester was reported as saying that over three years as many women had died by fire in the capital, chiefly through crinoline, as had been lost at Santiago. That was rhetoric, not a tally.
In 1862 the Medical Times and Gazette reported that the Bristol coroner had angered fellow citizens after an inquest on a young woman whose crinoline caught fire. He said that whenever he saw a woman, other than one of rank and importance, in crinoline, he took it for granted that she was hiding an unmarried pregnancy. Mitchell shows that worry about concealed pregnancy and infanticide ran alongside the fire stories, and that writers readily blamed feminine folly.
There was a practical remedy. The chemists Versmann and Oppenheim tested salts that might make light fabrics non-flammable. All the Year Round summarized their findings in 1862: borax rotted ironed muslin, phosphate of soda stiffened it, sulphate of ammonia worked for finishing new cloth, and for washing, in their words, “the tungstate of soda only can be recommended.” Treated muslins had been shown to the Queen. Tungstate of soda was sold with simple instructions: dissolve four ounces in a pint of water and dip the starched fabric. A writer held a treated scrap of lawn in a candle flame for a minute without its being consumed, and in another test only the part of treated muslin touching the flame burned.
Uptake was poor. A year later Lankester told the Princess’s Theatre inquest that the means of making dresses safe existed and were little used. He noted a claim in the Times that stage and ballroom dresses were never washed. If so, he said, the remedy for them was a matter of manufacture rather than laundry.
After its peak around 1862 the crinoline’s sweep narrowed. Skirts flattened at the front and fullness moved to the back, a trend that ended in the bustle. The crinoline years left a vivid and partly exaggerated public story, a handful of well-documented inquests, and figures that show how often Victorians burned without showing how many were killed by the hoop itself.