Supermarket refrigerators and freezers across Europe have been hit by cyberattacks that raised the temperature of internet-linked units, destroying and damaging large quantities of food. On Monday, fridges and freezers at more than 100 shops in several European countries ran hot. The incidents began last month, when hundreds of French supermarkets were left with spoiled food and damage to units that had overheated, at a cost of millions of euros.
Dutch operator Delhaize said dozens of its shops in Belgium and Luxembourg were hit by what it called an IT incident. French retailer Carrefour said about 15 of its 700 Belgian locations had refrigeration problems. The Colruyt group, which runs Spar stores in Belgium as franchises, said five shops were affected. Swedish Coop said cooling systems at seven of its 800 stores were disrupted, from complete shutdowns to partial operation. Furniture retailer IKEA said one site in Mons, Belgium, which also has a restaurant, was affected by a cyberattack.
Belgian butchery chain De Laet & Van Haver said the temperature in fridges at its store in Hove, south of Antwerp, rose as high as 18 degrees Celsius, ruining meat worth about 15,000 euros (16,764 dollars). Food wholesaler Musgrave said a cyber incident affected refrigeration in 13 SuperValu stores in Ireland. In October, hundreds of French supermarkets suffered cyberattacks that spoiled tonnes of food, caused fires and melted parts of refrigeration units.
In August, freezers at a market on Fort Huachuca, an Army base in Arizona, went into defrost mode and spoiled all the frozen food they held, the base said on Facebook. The same month, the naval station in Newport, Rhode Island, reported that its refrigeration system was affected and that only dry goods were available. The Pentagon treated the military-base freezer malfunctions as a suspected hack, Reuters reported late last month, citing four officials close to the matter. One official said Pentagon investigators were in contact with the French authorities.
Hackers can reach the controls of fridges and freezers that use internet software and raise the temperature so frozen food spoils. In some European supermarkets, temperatures were pushed as high as 50C (122F), causing appliances to melt or catch fire.
Awais Rashid, a professor of cybersecurity at the University of Bristol, said many supermarket refrigeration systems are managed remotely, often by third parties, and have not received the software updates needed to keep hackers out. He told Al Jazeera that, in line with established cybersecurity practice, these systems should be managed via secure networks, but in these incidents they were accessible on the internet. A remote manager can use a web server on the controller to change settings, including temperature, and to carry out maintenance. He said several controllers, many of them past end of life, have known vulnerabilities, including easily guessable passwords that would let anyone gain access.
The motive is unclear. Authorities believe the attacks may be a deliberate attempt to disrupt food supplies. On Monday, European Commissioner for Agriculture and Food Christophe Hansen called the fridge attacks a deliberate attempt to disrupt the bloc’s food supply and undermine consumer confidence. He said food security was not currently at risk, while the food waste and the impact on businesses were real.
Rashid said few details are known about who is behind the attacks or why, and that the motive is likely disruption. He said the incidents have financial effects on supermarkets and wider effects on the security of the food supply chain, and that they risk undermining trust in infrastructure people rely on every day.
On Monday, Belgium’s prosecutor’s office said it had opened a criminal investigation into the latest fridge cyberattacks. No one has claimed responsibility.
Rashid added that as infrastructure is digitised, the risk of disruption to cyber-physical systems such as refrigeration has risen, while much everyday digital infrastructure still runs safely because sound security practice is followed. He said it matters that all businesses follow good cybersecurity practice.